|
|
presents
Book Review,
March 2001:
The
Complete AR-15/M16 Sourcebook
by Duncan Long Paladin Press, 1992, softcover 224 pages ISBN 0-9676896-1-9 $29.95 |
1. Assume that the reader is an intelligent individual able to assimilate a variety of concepts.Using this approach, the Dummies books have effectively taught complex subjects ranging from Unix to Windows to relational databases to countless people who swore they'd never be able to tell a grep from a .ini file from a replication error. Despite the apparent simplicity with which the books are written, they remain a formidable resource for the veteran as well as the novice.
2. Break each concept down to its most fundamental elements
3. Explain each of those elements without using jargon or abstruse technical terminology
4. Use analogies and illustrations whenever possible.
5. Use a building block approach where each concept follow naturally from the last.
While the Dummies books are well designed and executed, the concept is hardly new. Duncan Long's The Complete AR-15/M16 Sourcebook is an excellent example the paradigm's application to firearms. And what a topic Mr. Long has chosen! The AR-15/M16 family of rifles are among the most controversial, ubiquitous, complex, and copied designs ever produced. An exposition of the aftermarket industry devoted to these rifles alone could fill volumes. It is into this confusing warren that Long thrusts his readers, offering his volume as a guide and roadmap.
As guides go, the book is a good one, carefully organized into eleven chapters and four appendices:
Chapter 1: The History of the AR-15 RifleLong's writing exhibits great literary pedagogical ability and patience as he shows the reader where the AR-15 came from, what it is, how it works, how to build it, and on a whirlwind tour of the accessories and equipment available for the rifle. While the text's diction and syntax won't win Mr. Long any awards from the Modern Language Association, it is carefully constructed so as to convey the maximum amount of information to the greatest number of readers in the most efficient manner possible, as these excerpts demonstrate:
Chapter 2: Failures, Problems and Solutions
Chapter 3: Colt's AR-15 Variations
Chapter 4: Grenades, SPIWs, and the AR-15
Chapter 5: Other AR-15's
Chapter 6: Operating the AR-15
Chapter 7: Cleaning and Disassembling the AR-15
Chapter 8: Assembling the AR-15
Chapter 9: Accessories for the AR-15
Chapter 10: Selective-Fire Conversions
Chapter 11: Troubleshooting the AR-15
Appendix A: Accessory Manufacturers
Appendix B: Ammunition Manufacturers
Appendix C: Firearms Manufacturers and Importers
Appendix D: A Bibliography of Books, Magazines, and (Even) Videotape About the AR-15
In fact, it's probable that Johnson himself had a hand in some of the developmental work with the AR-10 because he was on ArmaLite's payroll as "military rifle consultant and publicist," perhaps one of the odder job descriptions of the century. At any rate, one of the most important features of the Johnson Light Machine Gun to find its way into the AR-10 was the cam-controlled rotary bolt, which locked into the barrel rather than the receiver, making it possible to use a lightweight aluminum receiver with the firearm since the barrel supported all the gas pressure produced when the weapon was fired.
(From Chapter 8: Assembling
the AR-15)
Lower Receiver Assembly
Despite its usefulness as a reference and a resource, there are a couple of improvements we'd like to see. The book is a good reference, but would be even better if it had an index. The lack of an index makes the book significantly less useful than it could be. The current edition of The Complete AR-15/M16 Sourcebook was published in 1992. This was prior to the Brady Act's "ban" on military style self loading rifles, and the tremendous impact that it had on the firearms industry. We'd like to see an updated edition of the book that incorporates data about the ban and its impact on the AR-15 community, as well as the technological advances that have been applied to the rifle in the last ten years.
Additionally, we'd like to see Paladin Press publish a "shop" edition of the book, preferably one in an oil resistant three ring binder with punched pages and a detailed index. Ideally, this version of the book would be a "living" text with periodic updates mailed out on a subscription basis.
In the final analysis, The Complete AR-15/M16 Sourcebook is an excellent companion volume to the AR-15 rifle, and certainly one that the firearms novice who find himself in possession of an AR-15 should own. The clear, lucid and logical writing style is one that technical writers of any given subject would do well to imitate, and the illustrations are an excellent template for illustrating a point without overwhelming the reader. While rough around the edges, and somewhat dated, Long's work remains de rigeur reading for AR-15 aficionados.
The Complete
AR-15/M16 Sourcebook
is available from
Amazon.com. Click on the image to order: